Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

ethics and AI

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #16
    Originally posted by the Riddler View Post
    More valley than uncanny? Realistically, you'd never mistake her for a human.

    That's what I find unethical, though, it toys with even our perception of ourselves.

    I do not think its possible to jive human motor functions with a not self-aware AI, though.

    Don't you think that's kind of sick? I do.
    If possible, I don't think creating self-awareness is sick in-and-of itself, I think it potentially offers insight into aspects of consciousness that philosophers have been contemplating for centuries, if not millennia, and possibly helps people better understand aspects of cognition and psychology. Of course, there could be unintended consequences.

    As far as a human look, that does seem like a weird kind of vanity, placing an aware machine in a human looking body. I can understand making it anthropomorphic to help navigate the environment but I think something like C-3p0 with more human facial features and agile movement would suffice. I don't like the idea of replicating human skin tones and fine details.

    Maybe it would decide it wants to inhabit other types of bodies and creates an octopus body for itself that it chooses to inhabit on Thursdays or something.




    Originally posted by tumbling.dice View Post
    Consider just the self-awareness part, whether robot or computer or whatever. Say you design a self-aware computer to help understand the laws of physics, but it decides it doesn't care for physics and wants to be a writer or something. Do you try to force it? Threaten to shut it off if it doesn't do want you want? If so then we're acting like God.
    Some might liken it more to slavery. It's interesting to ponder if people would value it in the same way as carbon based life or is there something about having a heart and organs where we don't view the mere computational self-awareness in the same way and it results in us not having much empathy towards it. It's a bit wild to think of a scenario where you could fully communicate and interact with a robot but still think more highly of a cat or dog.

    Comment


      #17
      Don't really know much about AI yet, other than how it reacts to posters on fakebook.

      People often get banned or punished for something totally obscure.
      mother moon -she's calling me back to her silver womb,
      father of creation -takes me from my stolen tomb
      seventh-advent unicorn is waiting in the skies,
      a symptom of the universe, a love that never dies!
      🧙‍♂️

      Comment


        #18
        Originally posted by Audiogen View Post
        I think something like C-3p0 with more human facial features and agile movement would suffice. I don't like the idea of replicating human skin tones and fine details.
        agree. it just seems weird and pointless to try to make them indistinguishable from humans.

        I think when conscious AI comes about, it will not see the need or desire to be confined to any one kind of body, anyway. It won't have to be.

        Comment


          #19
          Some good subject matter for books or movies/tv. Besides I Robot there's also:

          Äkta människor (Real Humans)
          Äkta människor: Created by Lars Lundström. With Lisette T. Pagler, Pia Halvorsen, Johan Paulsen, Natalie Minnevik. In a parallel present the artificial human has come into its own. Robots no longer have anything robot-like about them. New technology and advancements in the field of science have made it possible to manufacture a product - a kind of mechanized servant - that is so similar to a real human that it can often be considered a perfectly good substitute. The Human Robot (HUBOT) have also given rise to new problems and dilemmas. Thorny legal questions have increasingly started to occupy people's minds and are still waiting to be answered: Who is responsible for the actions of a hubot? Do hubots have some form of "hubot rights"? Should they be paid for their work? As an ever growing number of people form relationships with hubots, the boundaries between human and machine become blurred. When humans make copies of themselves, which are so close to the real thing they form emotional bonds, the questions arises - What does it really mean to be 'human'?


          and

          Better than us
          Better Than Us: Created by Alexander Kessel. With Paulina Andreeva, Kirill Käro, Aleksandr Ustyugov, Olga Lomonosova. A family on the brink of splitting up become the owners of a cutting-edge robot being sought by a corporation, homicide investigators and terrorists.


          I found both pretty interesting and entertaining, although the russian one is more a thriller/suspense series. Real Humans is a danish production btw, and definitely more interesting in regards to ethics and AI. Hope you can find and watch it somewhere! Better than us is likely readily available on Netflix or something, as it is in my country

          Comment


            #20
            Originally posted by Audiogen View Post

            Maybe it would decide it wants to inhabit other types of bodies and creates an octopus body for itself that it chooses to inhabit on Thursdays or something.






            Some might liken it more to slavery. It's interesting to ponder if people would value it in the same way as carbon based life or is there something about having a heart and organs where we don't view the mere computational self-awareness in the same way and it results in us not having much empathy towards it. It's a bit wild to think of a scenario where you could fully communicate and interact with a robot but still think more highly of a cat or dog.
            That's a neat idea, robots changing bodies.

            Comment


            • Din Djarin
              Din Djarin commented
              Editing a comment
              Altered carbon (based on books. Didn't Audiogen read those??) revolves around being able to change bodies (not robots though, 'just' humans :P )

            • Audiogen
              Audiogen commented
              Editing a comment
              Din Djarin I saw the first season on Netflix but did not know that was based on books.

            #21
            I like the film 'Her', which was way deeper regarding this subject than the trailer made me think it would be. The guy falling in love with his computer. But the showing of how fast the AI evolves beyond human understanding and compatibility is, I think, going to be accurate.

            Comment


              #22
              Originally posted by Din Djarin View Post
              Some good subject matter for books or movies/tv. Besides I Robot there's also:

              Äkta människor (Real Humans)
              Äkta människor: Created by Lars Lundström. With Lisette T. Pagler, Pia Halvorsen, Johan Paulsen, Natalie Minnevik. In a parallel present the artificial human has come into its own. Robots no longer have anything robot-like about them. New technology and advancements in the field of science have made it possible to manufacture a product - a kind of mechanized servant - that is so similar to a real human that it can often be considered a perfectly good substitute. The Human Robot (HUBOT) have also given rise to new problems and dilemmas. Thorny legal questions have increasingly started to occupy people's minds and are still waiting to be answered: Who is responsible for the actions of a hubot? Do hubots have some form of "hubot rights"? Should they be paid for their work? As an ever growing number of people form relationships with hubots, the boundaries between human and machine become blurred. When humans make copies of themselves, which are so close to the real thing they form emotional bonds, the questions arises - What does it really mean to be 'human'?


              and

              Better than us
              Better Than Us: Created by Alexander Kessel. With Paulina Andreeva, Kirill Käro, Aleksandr Ustyugov, Olga Lomonosova. A family on the brink of splitting up become the owners of a cutting-edge robot being sought by a corporation, homicide investigators and terrorists.


              I found both pretty interesting and entertaining, although the russian one is more a thriller/suspense series. Real Humans is a danish production btw, and definitely more interesting in regards to ethics and AI. Hope you can find and watch it somewhere! Better than us is likely readily available on Netflix or something, as it is in my country
              I've heard good things about Better than Us. Just for clarification, I do not recommend I Robot the movie. The movie bears little resemblance to the book, although I do think it mentions the Laws of Robotics but yah it's basically just a Will Smith Summer blockbuster. The book is composed of short stories and has different scenarios, even one in space.


              On this theme and movies, I do recommed Ex-Machina:
              Ex Machina: Directed by Alex Garland. With Domhnall Gleeson, Alicia Vikander, Oscar Isaac, Sonoya Mizuno. A young programmer is selected to participate in a ground-breaking experiment in synthetic intelligence by evaluating the human qualities of a highly advanced humanoid A.I.

              Comment


                #23
                Neural nets arent AI

                AI hasnt been invented yet

                Comment


                  #24
                  um, isn't that what silicon valley uses for processing their (our) algorhythms?
                  mother moon -she's calling me back to her silver womb,
                  father of creation -takes me from my stolen tomb
                  seventh-advent unicorn is waiting in the skies,
                  a symptom of the universe, a love that never dies!
                  🧙‍♂️

                  Comment

                  Working...
                  X